January 12, 2011

Dershowitz Defends Palin

In this report Harvard Law School Professor Alan Dershowitz defends Sarah Palin's metaphorical use of the term "blood libel." Glad some prominent defender of Israel stands up for her. But he adds to his comment the phrase "a mentally disturbed individual," apparently referring to Jared Loughner, the accused shooter of US Rep. Giffords in Arizona. Two questions arise. How does he know that? Is he making a psychiatric diagnosis? How reliable is that? Secondly if he has knowledge of Loughner's medical records how did he see them? Revealing medical records without consent is a violation of state and US privacy laws. Why are those laws only only enforced for non psychiatric patients? Why do journalists plaster across the media landscape psychiatric records (or anecdotal reports of psychiatric illness) while others are protected? At least if psychiatry was a legitimate medical specialty. But their illnesses are created by consensus. They testify in court giving their personal opinion masquerading as science. They predict the future! Here is one more example that the highest levels of prestigious American academics believe that there is substance to psychiatry other than the billions of taxpayer dollars wasted each year.

[from article]
"The term 'blood libel' has taken on a broad metaphorical meaning in public discourse," he said in a statement to biggovernment.com. "I myself have used it to describe false accusations against the State of Israel by the Goldstone Report. There is nothing improper and certainly nothing anti-Semitic in Sarah Palin using the term to characterize what she reasonably believes are false accusations that her words or images may have caused a mentally disturbed individual to kill and maim."

http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/blood-libel-sarah-palins-controversial-reference-riled-emotions/story?id=12601352

Death Threats Against Sarah Palin at 'Unprecedented Level,' Aides Say

Palin's Video Prompts Debate Over 'Blood Libel;' Palin's Office Talking to Security

No comments: