December 27, 2009

Humble Silver Spoon Origins?


[The New York Post published an edited version of this letter on Sunday December 27, 2009.]

***Here is the original followed by what the Post published.***

Callahan says, "Woods, especially, has a lot in common with Obama: a mixed-race child of humble origins [. . .] first minority to break through a historically white institution." (MAUREEN CALLAHAN, "Can we forgive Tiger?" New York Post, December 20, 2009) Obama's father the Finance Minister of Kenya was brought to Harvard by US Senator Ted Kennedy. How was Barack a child of humble origins attending exclusive private schools and elite Ivy League Universities? Woods father was a US Army Lt. Colonel with all of the benefits. Was his skin color considered humble? What do journalists call foster children, orphans, and others who are really deprived?Still idealizing Obama and Woods?

http://www.nypost.com/p/news/opinion/opedcolumnists/can_we_forgive_tiger_yTIQYoiRMIe1bCZXZ6LxAJ

Can we forgive Tiger?
Of course! In America, we forgive everyone
By MAUREEN CALLAHAN
New York Post
Last Updated: 1:39 PM, December 20, 2009
Posted: 1:01 AM, December 20, 2009

***Published version***

http://www.nypost.com/p/news/opinion/letters/humble_ha_1M6MsDQJYz7MJO95ms9OCL

Humble? Ha!
Roy Bercaw
New York Post
Letter
Last Updated: 2:56 AM, December 27, 2009
Posted: 2:56 AM, December 27, 2009

Maureen Callahan writes, “Tiger Woods, especially, has a lot in common with Obama: a mixed-race child of humble origins. . . first minority to break through a historically white institution” (“Can We Forgive Tiger?” PostScript, Dec. 20).

How was it that President Obama, a child of humble origins, attended exclusive private schools and elite Ivy League universities?

Tiger Woods’ father was a US Army lieutenant colonel with all of the benefits. Was his skin color considered humble?

What do journalists call foster children, orphans and others who are really deprived?

Still idealizing Obama and Woods?

Roy Bercaw, Cambridge, Mass.

No comments: