March 9, 2008

Irrational Reasoning

Irrational Reasoning

The Editors at The New York Times refer to "the powerful gun
lobby" but ignore the more powerful psychiatric lobby.
(Editorial, "Gun Crazy," The New York Times, March 1, 2008) They
regularly criticize the President, the Governor and the Mayor. But
they seldom if ever question psychiatrists. Are psychiatrists better
deceivers than politicians?
Referring to "deranged individuals [who shoot up] crowded
classroom[s] or shopping mall[s]"
they support the irrational belief that persons accused of mental
illness are violent. Why give
credence to illnesses that only psychiatrists can see?
The psychiatric industry insists that stopping taking their drugs
causes violence. Why begin
taking drugs if stopping causes violence? Is it good for business?
Contrary to evidence the editors call a "wacky idea" (See John R.
Lott's "More Guns, Less Violence," U. Chicago Press, 2000.)
the editors suggest that stronger gun control laws are needed. More
legal guns will reduce violence.
Using mental health data bases will only demonize persons with 'a
history of mental illness." That
will be used for more deprivations of rights to persons with
disabilities. It will not decrease gun violence.
The criminals will continue to get their guns. Persons with
disabilities will have one more right denied to them.

Roy Bercaw - Editor ENOUGH ROOM

March 1, 2008
Editorial
Gun Crazy
New York Times

No comments: