May 18, 2007

Dangerous Propaganda

Dangerous Propaganda

Marc Seigel asks, "Is there any science behind the fears of these useful
meds?"(MARC K. SIEGEL, "DANGEROUS WARNINGS," New York Post, May 12, 2007, Page
21) Better unasked questions are "Is there any science behind the mental illnesses
created by consensus? Is there any science behind the fantasy that there is a
biological basis to mental illness? Is there any science behind the personal
opinions of psychiatrists?" The answers are no, no and no.
The American Psychiatric Association is unable to provide any evidence of
their claim of a biological basis for mental illness. Does Marc Seigel receive
any funding from any of the drug companies or their lobbyists? What explains his
misguided propaganda encouraging use of anti depressants which are a proven
cause of violence among humans?
[Dr. Siegel responded to my email assuring me that he does not get any money from drug companies.]
--
Roy Bercaw, Editor ENOUGH ROOM

DANGEROUS WARNINGS
New York Post
By MARC K. SIEGEL

May 12, 2007 -- CONGRESS may soon increase the Food and Drug Administration's
oversight of pharmeceuticals. I certainly don't think we should simply trust
what drug companies tell us, but I have my worries about the FDA, too.

Why? Consider one of my patients. Last year, the teen was in trouble - fighting
with both parents during an ugly divorce and becoming severely depressed and
violent. He'd had a fistfight with a relative and been expelled from his school
[...]
Dr. Marc K. Siegel is author of "False Alarm."

No comments: