Showing posts with label Plato. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Plato. Show all posts

November 12, 2015

Harvard University Scholars Unable To Define Human Nature




Two biologists, a psychologist, and a historian remain unable to define human nature. To bad there were no Greek and Roman Classicists, or a Medievalist. They might be able to add to the discussion. Humans have not changed for thousands of years. Where was the Biblical scholar, Chinese and Japanese historians and the Egyptologists?

http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2015/11/12/mind-brain-behavior-rage-event/

Professors Discuss Rage at Interdisciplinary Symposium
By MIA C. KARR
CONTRIBUTING WRITER
Harvard Crimson
November 11, 2015

July 20, 2015

United States Government Has Gone Off the Rails of Constitutional Republic




[From article]
A representative party is one in which elected officials carry out some close approximation of the desires of the people they claim to represent. The party serves to aggregate the most articulate individuals from a group of people who share some common interests. Those individuals may be innovative to some degree, but they should not drag their constituents in directions that they would not naturally go. Representative are just that -- representatives.



[. . .]
Thus, in principle, all decisions made by government were made with the consent of the governed.
[. . .]
The representative model is now defunct, destroyed in somewhat different ways by the two political parties.
[. . .]



The Democratic party of today is not a representative party, but a top-down political machine organized around a reformulation of traditional socialist ideology.
[. . .]
a small group of intellectuals drawn almost exclusively from a handful of elite universities. Trusting the public will is a laughable proposition for academics, who consider themselves a superior breed -- like the philosopher kings of Plato’s Republic.
[. . .]
At a practical rather than an ideal level, socialism has never been particularly democratic. The socialist state has always been the instrument of one or another narrow group of planners, not answerable to the public’s will.
Moreover, the actual Democratic Party of today is actually a degenerate socialist party, often mixing crony capitalist practice uncomfortably with socialist rhetoric. Obama’s speeches, and perhaps his self image, aren’t all that different from Fidel Castro’s -- but he does have a far wealthier circle of friends.
[. . .]



At the risk of being called racist, the Republican Party seems to function more or less as the nameless team that plays against the Harlem Globetrotters. They provide the illusion of a contest to events that have been carefully choreographed in advance.
[. . .]
Most Republican politicians, in short, have come to represent no one but themselves.
[. . .]
When our government becomes powerful enough to ignore the public, it becomes something fundamentally different from what it was. When the law is made up on the fly, the very concept of the law is rendered meaningless. No amount of outrage, or satisfyingly rational arguments, will let us vote our way out of an oligarchy.

http://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2015/07/the_logic_of_elitism.html

July 18, 2015
The Logic of Elitism
By E. M. Cadwaladr

April 1, 2010

Lawyers Run Courts as a Business

Surprise! Courts are a business and a sport run for and by licensed attorneys. It is a game that one side wins. Sometimes the fix is in. Most times it is based on who is more diligent or negligent. A sleeping attorney is competent counsel according to the Supreme Court of the US. Courts allow only "evidence" as testimony. Truth is not what courts find. Cases are decided based on evidence. In Plato's Republic where justice is discussed, Thrasymachus suggests that justice is "the interests of the stronger." Does that explain why wealthy, politically connected defendants get away with murder?

http://bostonherald.com/news/columnists/view/20100401mom_reels_after_2nd_mistrial_in_sons_slay_we_still_have_no_justice/srvc=home&position=2

Mom reels after 2nd mistrial in son’s slay

‘We still have no justice’

By Margery Eagan
Boston Herald
Thursday, April 1, 2010

November 1, 2009

Justice Is?


“I came to law school because I care about justice,” Minow said. “The question of justice should be present in the classroom, present in the work of scholars, present in the career aspirations. What justice is, of course, is a very complicated matter.” In Plato's Republic seven definitions of Justice were discussed. To Thrasymachus Justice is the interests of the stronger. History and Harvard lawyers accept this view.

http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=529855

Martha Minow Faces Challenges
Published On Friday, October 30, 2009 1:29 AM
By ELIAS J GROLL
Harvard Crimson Staff Writer